Aftermath
Rhy was definitely moving his head and fingers and feet to the music to all of them, but here are his specific reactions:
STEVEN UNIVERSE Rhy REALLY liked “Still Not Giving Up” because wow, sounds like his life. It made him FEEL THINGS. He likes You Are My Sunshine too, and the last one has him FEELING THINGS again. Damn, Steven. (He was also looking at Alucard fairly often during that last one).
MARCELINE First one put him in a romantic mood, and he was smiling a lot. Second one was another feelings punch right in the heart. And man, so is the third one. YOU GUYS ARE MAKING THIS DIFFICULT.
OUT OF THIS WORLD He liked the first song with the guitar riffs, but the lyrics of the other two didn’t appeal to him nearly as much.
Ultimately he had a real hard time deciding between the first two, but voted for Marceline in the end because her songs hit him in the deeper, darker feels. He definitely wants to hear more of Steven's work as well, tho, and would love to hear them jam together!