Ariana
I have no idea, but I think having a few alies would still be better in the long run than hoarding all of the water for myself, wouldn't it? Besides, it's not as if i can't kill you if you decide to turn on me.
I won't tell her, but do you mind if I ask why? Does she not like people who talk about disturbing things while under the influence of an 'evil' house, or does she just not like you talking to men?
In fairness to her, taking it from her wasn't exactly harmless, but it didn't cause her any permanent problems at all. Considering the fact that she likes to think of herself as a good person, you would think she would be a little bit more charitable.