Kidnapping
Lily closed her eyes again, shaking her head as he asked. "I don't know!" she said, her voice still whispered but through gritted teeth. "I was...I was with Avery," she said, disappointment and shame obvious in her voice. "Please don't ask, it was...it was stupid and now I know it wasn't right. But I don't know what he would have against me! He wanted to talk about that blasted list that's been going around the school and he offered safety from anything happening..." As she said it out loud, she felt completely ashamed of herself.
She chanced to look back out and saw another witch had come up behind Rodolphus, one she hadn't recognized. "Do you have your wand?" she asked James. "It looks to only be two...we could take them." She looked up at him, hope in her eyes. She knew they couldn't run, they'd find them anyway.