Eek. The fact he couldn't muster a proper smile was enough to make her want to cringe. She wouldn't, of course, because that wouldn't help at all. After a short pause Sara returned his smile, "Hey.." before stepping inside, shivering for a second from the change in temperature.
She fell silent then, which was very unusual for a girl who usually had a million things to say. Girls talk too much, except for right now, apparently. Honestly? She was shocked when he asked her for a drink, even though it was the normal thing to do. Sara didn't know what she'd been expecting when she came here but... this just seemed odd. Awkward. And that’s the last thing she wanted to be feeling right now.
"Sure. Do you have any hot chocolate?" Before she could stop herself she was glancing around his apartment. It didn’t matter how many times she came here, she’d still be curious. “Have I told you that you have a really nice place before?” Small talk. That's just great.