Katie had been expecting Alicia's answer, really, was ready to giggle along with her at her mother's taste and the awful time Alicia had, just as they always did.
But then. Katie nearly choked mid-bite, taken aback by Alicia's offered information. "Pucey Pucey?! Slytherin git Pucey?!" She then dropped her slice of pizza back into the box with a playful grimace, shaking her head and brushing her hands together as if to get the crumbs off. "I'm done." Seriously. What?!
Katie knew there was more to the story or Alicia would've owled her right afterwards and they would've gotten a good laugh out of it immediately. But she tried to conceal her suspicion (and slight hurt, maybe, at having been so out of the loop) through her looks of disgust toward this offered information.
((Sorry I've been so sparse with replies; stuff in my RL has really thrown me for a loop this week [think new semester PLUS hospital news]... I'll try to be better about it.))