Enchanted is the most trite thing I've heard/seen for ages. I hate musicals and that was probably the worst I've been exposed to for some time. I just wasted 1.5 hour to watch Sweeney Todd. Damned, I could have used that time to break a leg or eat my left eye and still have had more fun.
James Marsden's a plus, I agree. Naked. Whether he's singing or not.
I have music the boys would have listened to. I am sure Sevvie would have loved Stranglers. It's so lovely dark and angry, and would fit him well at the time. *smirks* Honestly, I don't think he'd have listened to any Muggle music at all. If it should be something eery and odd from that time that could resemble wizard music, Brian Eno's Ambient (however, very Muggle. "On Land" would probably do) or Siouxsie maybe.
And I have eight hours of Abba, not that I like them, but one of my friends gave them to me because he knew I'd be annoyed. Saved them just to play them every time he visits. He's tired of them by now. :D Remus' is an Abba guy, or ELO. Cheery fellow and all...
We so need a musical round table. What would they really like, the two of them? It's an interesting discussion. I doubt, really, that Remus's a swing/jazz guy, like Warner Bastards want us to believe.