You are my favourite full stop! This is the world's most wonderful, happy-making feedback! I will save it to reread whenever I'm feeling discouraged about my writing.
I am so delighted by the idea of the fight in comic strip form, I can't even tell you. That's pretty much exactly how it looked in my head.
Thank you for quoting the bits that really worked for you! It always delights me so when people highlight my pet lines. The salubrious exchange went through about a million rewrites before I came up with that zinger for Snape, so I am super extra thrilled you thought it was funny (but not too funny coming hard on the heels of Harry's emotional rant).
I thought about selecting Humour as my genre (rather than Humour/Crack), but as I had only written about a quarter of the story when I had to make the decision, I decided it would be safer to keep the backslash. I think you're right though - in the end though, it turned out to be much less of a crack fic than I had expected.
Thank you again so much for this lovely, thoughtful comment. I just hope I'm still able to fit through the office door with my enormously swelled head!