sʜᴀᴅᴏᴡ ʀɪsᴇs ᴏᴏᴄ

I need help!

I suckered myself into a new character and I don't know the face I should choose. I narrowed it to two of them. 1 or 2.

Character is going to be a mild mannered piano player who often gets into fights with the keys. (original, I know)

Just a heads up I've changed Silas pb because... ( well )