Hello! I'm HannahGrace. Welcome to the party. I've not seen The Magicians but Margo looks very cool!
I have these guys:
Cappie downandirty - Cappie is from Greek. He's... Cappie. If you don't know him already, you will pretty soon. He's my loudest muse and he's a massive flirt. He's also very comfortable with the knowledge that he's in a tv show so no worries about puncturing there. In fact, he's very similar to Margo in his pop-culture referencing habit.
Danny Walker looklikeahero - Literally the complete opposite of Cappie, Danny is the super sweet, doomed guy from Pearl Harbour. He came from moments before his last scene in the movie *cough* so he's a bit messed up. He's awkward but cute. Margo will scare him. He's already punctured and I love torturing him so feel free to mention the war.
Eleanor Guthrie queenofnassau - Eleanor used to be the black market trade boss and HBIC of Nassau. She (mostly) did a good job of keeping the pirates in line and she built a pretty formidable empire for herself there. She fell from grace, though, and was almost hanged before a new opportunity presented itself. I don't actually think she's been punctured yet but I'm not at all concerned for when it happens. She fairly pragmatic plus she knows a lot of cool pirates and isn't above boasting.
Just give me a shout if you fancy anything with any of them!