Em/Everleigh
Listen, I'm doing this here because I'm really not looking to be responsible for any kind of panic.
The reason why no one has really said anything is either because they're worried about causing a panic or because it's unlikely they'll be believed. It's just easier to let people come to the answer on their own time.
Basically this reality isn't real. I don't remember you from Atlantis before so it's unlikely that you'll know the place. It's where most of us have been staying for months to years. I honestly haven't been there for very long so I'm not really an expert. We don't know why this happened but my real name isn't Everleigh. It's Emmeline Vance, and I'm not a Detective, I'm a witch, used to be an Auror. Something happened and we all got fake identities.
That's why things feel off. Our true selves are trying to slip through whatever magic is taking place here.