If they're granting wishes, they're granting wishes. That doesn't mean they won't get their laughs from taking advantage of a vague one.
"Be careful what you wish for."
Carly... you never really met her, but she was a girl on Orion. She decided she didn't want anything to do with her past life, and wished to go home with her teammate. And we actually heard from her later. She sounded really happy, and... she told me something that the Judges couldn't possibly know to fake. It was really her.