Thanks for the warm wishes! I reviewed your game page, and apart from being AU Nolan-inspired, we will be diverging a bit, yeah. We won't be doing the No Man's Land arc any time soon if at all, though there are elements of Battle for the Cowl at play (hopefully better, I wasn't a huge fan of most of that arc). We're leaning a bit closer to the comics in terms of characters allowed and the existence of some fantastic elements (such as Clayface, Ivy's plants), hoping to find that right fusion between Nolan realism and comics variety.
The challenges and plot posts will help drive the main thrust of the larger plot, but we fully expect and hope players will also generate their own stories and plots that fit within the game. Self-motivated players will, by generating their own content, also shape the larger part of the game, and those who may be short on ideas in a given period of time will be able to use our prompts. Our primary love is still characters, interaction with each other, and telling compelling stories that give us a stake in those characters' lives!