Elena, Molly and OTA
That was a fairly common reaction to Clay, so Elena was used to it and it didn't even spark her jealousy anymore. Mostly because she knew that there was no way Clay was ever going to look at another woman, even if there had been points in time where she desperately wished he would.
"Wizards?" she repeated. That was... different. Of course, she shouldn't be surprised since she was a werewolf. At least it would explain why the girl smelled like something other than a regular human. "Guessing you don't know anything about how we got here?"