I know, I know, it's been a while, and they kind of, um, piled up. *sheepish* 99 total. *hides*
Official count:
64 Supernatural icons 5 Colby Granger from Numb3rs icons 4 Jensen Ackles icons 1 text icon 2 Jared Padalecki icons 4 Christian Kane icons 2 Milo Ventimiglia icons 1 cats icon 7 Keith Urban icons 2 Nightwish band member(s) icons 2 Dylan Bruno icons 2 Diane Farr icons 1 Vin Tanner from The Magnificent Seven icon 2 Spike from Buffy the Vampire Slayer icons