The Curse of the Red Cape
Need to use the restroom and don't want to travel all the way to your dorm room? Perhaps you're in the science building? You shouldn't sit in the last stall though.
Do you want red paper or blue paper?
[[ SELECT RED? ]] Your skin gets sliced until your clothes gets stained red. [[ SELECT BLUE? ]] You can't breathe, strangled until your face turns blue. [[ ANOTHER COLOR? ]] You might get pulled into what can only be a hallucination of the Netherworld. Lasts overnight, you wake up in bed the next morning. [[ DECLINE OFFER. ]] Nothing happens. How strange.
All options leave you surviving, but it all feels real.