Crowley
Well, there's the obvious, but Gabriel would never forgive me for that. If I have to choose between archangels, it'll always be Gabe. Sorry not sorry, I love you and I want you happy but I'm keeping him.
I'm not eager to do another full enchantment, being inside an archangel's head is uncomfortable even in the best of times. I could take a little peek, if you wanted, just so you can find out how he feels about you.
Or I could slip him something that will make him act on whatever feelings he has.
Not to be mean, but he seems like a pretty blunt instrument. Chuckie's big ol' 'knock it off' hammer. You might be better off looking him in the eye and just saying 'let me take you to dinner and buy you flowers or give you this former hellhound puppy, after that we can go back to my place and I'll teach you how to do things to me that would horrify both of our creators' or something like that in a sexier accent.
Anyway, that's really gross and I'm glad I didn't know at the time because I probably would have noped out of there and let Azrael kill him.
But good, I'll be right over. Sending Charles Barkley back home first.