She's not as forgiving as all that. His man noises mean nothing to her. The others howl for Jack to be thrown over. They try to dump him out before she eats him where they can't get any.
Her tail flaps along with the rocking boat and her anger. She picks up the rum bottle sliding back and forth in the bottom of the boat and smashes it- screaming in a high pitched wail. The other two pull themselves up, one clawing deep gauges in Jack's arm. The black haired one finally shows her ruined face, grabbing onto Jack from the other side. Her cheek hangs off in red angry strips of meat.