3
who: dustin, iv & theo setting: theo's room nsfw
Theo had reached the end of his rope. He’d given them time and space and cuddles and limited himself to getting off on his own in the shower, but he was done, done, done. No more. He texted the both of them, inviting them over for drinks and dinner or just to hang, got an agreement from both, then he printed out the sign.
No one permitted while clothed
He taped it to his bedroom door, then shut himself inside and got the place ready. Sure, he was putting a mandate out there, but he was willing to make it worth their while at least. He changed the sheets, lit a few flameless candles he’d found at the store and placed them around the room. Everything they could need was out, easy reach on the nightstand, champagne was chilling in an ice bucket off to the side. He even set some soft music, then stripped out of his clothes and flopped back on the bed to wait, letting his mind drift to all the things he wanted desperately to do both Iv and Dustin and the things he wanted done to himself as well.
Dustin had a lot on his mind. He needed to tell them about the latest guest in the brig, but wasn’t sure about bringing up those particular wounds. And wounds they were, he knew that for damn fucking sure. When he got the text from Theo, he read it, and considered.
Maybe telling them could wait. Maybe this was kind of what he needed right now anyway. He still didn’t know what the Captain was going to decide to do about their guest anyway, so right now saying anything might just stir things up with no way of putting them back to bed. So he just headed there with the intention to wing it, and probably just try to forget about it himself for a little while. When he got into the cabin, he looked around, then spotted the sign. He chuckled to himself, smiling. Okay, then.
He took a second to try and chase his self consciousness away, then did as the sign demanded, and ditched his clothes. Sure they were folded neatly and set on the floor outside the door but still. That left him with his dogtags and the pendant next to them that Theo had given him. He knocked on the door with the backs of his knuckles twice before he opened up the door and took a step inside. He’d really gone all out, hadn’t he? And there he was on the bed. “So I get the impression that you might miss us,” he remarked, smiling at the other man.
Theo had gotten ever so slightly impatient and might have half heartedly started without anyone else. Still, it wasn’t like the sight of a naked Dustin didn’t justify where Theo’s hand was when Dustin came in. Fuck his boyfriend was hot. Beyond hot. “Can you blame me?” he asked, giving Dustin a once over before sitting up and holding out a hand to him. “Look at you.”
Dustin definitely saw that Theo had started without them, though it didn't look like he'd got too far into the process. He smiled, and maybe his cheeks colored a little bit. When Theo reached out for him, he took his hand and let him draw him closer. “Look at you,” he countered. Theo was a hell of a specimen too. In fact the only male Dustin was attracted to. He still kept waiting for someone to cross his path and make him look twice but it just didn't happen. It was all Theo, all day. “Missed you too, you know.”
“Right, because I can compete with actual abs.” Theo leaned in to press a line of kisses against those perfect abs. “Did you? Really? Because I was starting to get worried…” He pushed up onto his knees so he was closer to Dustin’s height. “Because you have no idea how much I’ve missed you.”
Dustin laughed. “Yes, I spend all day every day caring mostly about abs. I constantly bore you both to death with my ab obsession,” he said, looking down at Theo as he kissed him. “Clearly it's all I care about,” he said, as Theo was back up. He stepped closer to the edge of the bed. “I know,” he said, voice softer than usual. “Thank you for waiting,” he added, because he was in fact grateful for the time he'd been allotted. But he was also grateful for a little push back in the right direction, too.
“Babe, you could bore me whenever you want,” Theo said. “Especially if we’re talking about your body parts.” He could probably enjoy watching Dustin work out and Theo plus the gym wasn’t exactly a combination that made sense. Theo reached up to cup Dustin’s cheeks, pulling him down for a light kiss. “I’m always going to wait for you. For as long as you need.” He kissed Dustin once more. “But I really, really, really want you back. Need you back.”
Dustin relaxed into the kiss, returning it. It made him feel good to hear everything that was said. That he'd always wait, and that he needed him back now. “You have me,” he assured Theo. He reached out and pulled Theo flush against him, and deepened the kiss. He drew it out, wanting more.
Theo groaned, actually groaned, wrapping his arms around Dustin’s shoulders and neck to keep him close. “I need you,” he murmured against his lips. “I need you so badly. Want you. I’m going to start babbling about it if you don’t stop me.”
That was such a great sound in his ears. Yeah, he could listen to that for a long time. He put his arms around Theo to hold him there, kissing at his neck a little, letting his teeth graze there. He kissed up to his ear to speak to him, voice a low little rumble in his chest. “What do you need?” he asked, nipping at his earlobe while he was at it. “Tell me.”
Theo’s moan was low and in his chest, a rumble of a thing as Dustin’s kisses set his skin on fire. “Need to feel you. Need you to touch me. Make me cry out.” All of that. Every bit of it. Just Dustin. At least to start. He wanted Iv too, but he wanted to start somewhere. Needed to start somewhere.
Dustin wanted those things too. Right now he wanted nothing more than to get Theo crying out, begging for more. He wanted to get back to feeling like he belonged here, with Theo, with Iv – who he was sure would be along any time now. But he knew she wouldn't mind them getting started. He did reach down to grasp Theo, though, not making him wait at least for that part. To touch him and hopefully get him to feel things as he stroked.
The lack of hesitation was perfect. Sometimes, when Dustin wasn’t touching him or kissing him or distracting him completely, Theo thought about it. How Dustin went from zero to gay sex god and how that was somehow the hottest thing that ever was. Theo moaned again, hips moving out of his control as he buried his face in Dustin’s shoulder.
That was what he wanted. Dustin smiled, then stepped it up a little, feeling that bump in confidence he did whenever he got either of them sounding like that. He reached up with his free hand, and tipped Theo's face up, to make eye contact. “Look at me,” he told him, a light little bit of command in his voice, just an experiment.
Theo whimpered softly, but he nodded, taking that little order in stride. Fuck, he really did love when Dustin was bossy. And not in the ‘save your life way’. That was hot, sure, but thinking of sexy times when having his ass saved wasn’t really the right thing to do. No, he liked ‘telling you what to do in bed’ Dustin, who seemed to enjoy ordering his boy and girl around. “Yes, sir,” he murmured, edge of a tease to his voice. See? He could be a good soldier.
Dustin couldn't help the little grin he gave as Theo complied and said 'yes sir'. That – yeah. There was something to that. He liked it. Probably more than he should. Or maybe it was just a part of their sexual identity and he should quit worrying about it. Probably that. He watched Theo's eyes, then leaned in and kissed him, biting his lower lip a little bit before he pushed him abruptly back onto the bed, looking down at him with a hungry sort of expression before he finally knelt on the bed. He did take note that Theo'd really set everything up in the room. There was a lot going on there that they could play with. This was going to be interesting. “Can't get too far with things,” he told him. “Got to calm you down a little bit,” he observed.
Theo groaned at the kiss, at least until he was being pushed back and it turned into a bit of a yelp. Damn Dustin was strong. Not that Theo minded. Nope. “What? No,” he protested, edge of a whine to his voice, making grabby hands at Dustin. “I can go more than once.”
Ivanya had been expecting another night of snuggles and food and although she adored those times with her boys, she was itching for something more. But she wasn’t pushing. She was waiting, as patiently as her little heart would allow, for her boys to tell her they were ready.
So when she came to Theo’s room to find the note on the door, she couldn’t help but grin. And as she stripped out of the dress she wore, conveniently with nothing else on underneath it, she could hear Dustin and Theo inside and it was honestly the hottest thing she’d ever heard. So much so that she stalled, just listening to them with the door shut between them, for as long as she could stand it. She didn’t want to interrupt but she needed to confirm if this was a them-thing or an everyone thing.
Peeking her head through a crack in the door, she cleared her throat. “Is this a two person party or is there room for one more?”
Dustin grinned. “Gonna hold you to that,” he told Theo, and then there was Iv. He turned around, pulled the door open and bodily picked her up to caveman carry her to the bed. He gave a little growl and bit playfully at her side before throwing her down onto the bed next to Theo. “You’re always invited,” he told her, taking a second to look down at the two of them on the bed, naked. Yes, this was exactly what he wanted, needed. “If either of you even thought about taking off, I’d have to chase you down.”
“Damn well better,” Theo countered, but he was as distracted by Iv as Dustin was. He loved seeing Dustin grab her, Dustin look at both of them like that. Yes. Finally. They were back where they needed to be. He grinned at Iv, winking. “Maybe we should run, just to see you chase after us naked down the halls.” The neighbors would definitely talk then.
Iv didn’t have time to think before she was scooped up and tossed over Dustin’s shoulder. She did make a squeal sound when he bit at her, high pitched and ending in a laugh when he threw her onto the bed. She bounced there until she settled beside Theo and immediately all she could look at was how far along Theo already was.
Reaching up, she pushed her hair out of her eyes, the low candlelight glinting off the set of stackable rings Theo had given her for Valentine’s Day. “We could but I don’t think we’d win. He’s so fast.”
Dustin smirked as he watched them. “If you’re thinking of running I’ll just have to make sure you’re both too worn out to leave the bed at all,” he suggested. He made a show of looking around, thinking tonight was going to be interesting. He skirted the bed to Iv’s side, and he leaned over her, reaching out to trace his finger down the side of her face, getting her hair behind her ear while he was at it. “So, I asked Theo to tell me what he needed,” he told her, leaning closer to brush his lips against hers. It was almost a kiss. “He was a very good boy. Your turn.”
This went from zero to one hundred so quickly and Iv was all about it. She was already arching toward Dustin, keyed up from the sheer heat he was putting off. “I want to feel you both. Together,” she mewled, lips aching to get just one kiss from him.
Good boy. Shit, that should not have done things to him, but it definitely did things to him. Theo arched a brow at that, glancing over at Dustin, trying to catch his eyes so he could nod. Yes. He liked that idea. He liked that idea a lot. “I want to change my answer,” he said. “I want that too.”
Dustin almost laughed, but didn't, because right now he was kind of playing an interesting role, and he didn't want to ruin it. He did catch Theo's eye, and the nod. He knew Iv wanted a kiss, but he didn't give it quite yet, instead standing straight to look at the both of them. “I did ask what you needed...” he mused. “Want is something that's all fine and good, of course,” he said slowly, reaching out to trace his fingertips down the outside of Iv's thigh. Then he reached with his other hand to do the same to Theo. “Do you need us both?” he posed to Iv, then ticked his gaze to Theo. “What about you? I know you need to be left screaming tonight,” he said, and his voice was very clear with his intentions to follow through on that.
Iv was already feeling like a puddle, just listening to the way Dustin commanded the room. She shivered at his touch and leaned closer to Theo. If he wanted to play, she was absolutely going to make him work for it. So she ran her fingers up Theo's side, pressing her body against Theo's purposefully to push her skin against his and give Dustin a real view. “I need you both,” when answered, looking up at Dustin. “But we don't know what you need…”
Theo groaned, burying the noise against Iv’s skin. He pulled her closer when she moved next to him. “Until I’m hoarse,” he managed, but his voice broke halfway through it. “I need to be...needed. Wanted.”
As she turned toward Theo, there was more room for him and Dustin knelt on the bed, and crawled in behind Iv, lying on his side to face the both of them. He reached across Iv to Theo, brushing his thumb across his cheek for a moment before he kissed the back of Iv's neck. “You're both needed. And I always want you,” he told them both. “Now...Iv needs us both, where do you want us?” he asked, hand ghosting down Theo's shoulder, then he placed his hand on the other man's hip, pulling him closer to press them both closer in with Iv between them.
This was heaven. She could happily spend the rest of her life here, snuggled between them. Pressing her head against Theo's shoulder, she sighed when Dustin kissed her and let her eyes drift shut to just drink in this moment. “I want to feel you both together, at the same time. Please,” she ended, leaning more of her weight back into Dustin.
Theo caught it. He looked over her shoulder at Dustin, arching a brow, but he tangled his fingers in Iv’s hair to pull her up to look at her. “Who do you want behind you?” He asked her.
That was the question, now wasn’t it? Dustin was out of his element here, but he was feeling a real rush from it all. When Theo looked over at him, he held eye contact for a moment. Then, as he focused Iv on his eyes, Dustin took the opportunity to reach over to the bedside table to get lubricant. Inexperienced he was, that didn’t mean he was completely clueless, though.
With her face just inches from his, Iv leaned in and pressed her lips gently against Theo’s own. She'd given thought to this scenario before; had imagined it both ways but today she knew what she wanted. “You,” she answered Theo.
Theo smirked at Dustin before focusing on Iv, nodding when she said what she wanted. It probably made more sense anyway. He kissed her once more, something deep and heated. “Roll over for me, baby,” he murmured, snagging the lube from Dustin. “Then Dustin can be in control again.” He winked at the other man, just to tease.
Dustin watched the two of them and chuckled a little at the tease. “You know, both of you seem to like it when I’m in control…” he pointed out. He then turned to Iv, and kissed her, something starting out almost soft, but escalating quickly. He was waiting for it to change on her end, waiting for what would happen when Theo was where she wanted him.
Ivanya shifted until she was facing Dustin, listening to Theo with a smirk starting on her lips. “You’re just so good at it,” She said. But she let her words fall away as Dustin kissed her. She’d ventured into the territory of each of these actions by themselves, but never together and absently she thought of how completely at ease she was with this. Even now, with them pressed up against her, all she felt was worshipped.
“Course we do,” Theo said as he watched them kiss. That was a sight he’d missed, which distantly was a weird thing, but that didn’t make it any less true. He coated some of the lubricant on his fingers then slipped them between Iv’s legs to get her worked up before he really started.
Dustin was so at ease with it all that he didn’t even consciously recognize it. He was just in the moment with them, feeling like he was finally back. That he left everything else outside this room, and in here it was just the three of them. And maybe it was flowery of him, but it felt like they were strange soulmates, the three of them together. They had a balance that worked so well. They all brought different things to the table, but they were all needed. He only broke the kiss when he needed to breathe, and he didn’t go far. He kissed down her neck, trailing little bites.
Exhaling with a little sound, Iv leaned closer to Dustin when he trailed down her skin. She let the warmth of his kisses wash over her and when she felt Theo behind her, all she could do was give another happy moan. Shifting, she pressed her hips back toward Theo, eyes shut as she focused in on his fingers and Dustin’s lips.
Theo took his time, making sure that Dustin was keeping up with distracting her, pressing little kisses on her shoulders as he moved his fingers back, more lube, gentler touches. He didn’t rush, too concerned with not hurting her by doing this than by taking too much time. He knew Dustin would do his part. “Have you done this before baby,” he murmured as he slipped fingers in, working his hips so she could imagine that it was more than just him stretching gently. He couldn’t decide what he wanted the answer to be, yes or no, but he knew it that it wouldn’t matter. They’d make her forget everyone else she’d ever been with, just like they’d done to him.
Ivanya moaned again, her eyes shutting as she pressed her head into Dustin’s shoulder. The addition of Theo’s fingers and that intoxicating movement of his hips had her breath hitching as she slowly adjusted to his actions. She could feel the ache it started spread through her entire body. “Yes,” She admitted, voice stuck in her throat at first. “Only a couple times…”
Dustin wasn't surprised by that at all. He'd be more hard pressed to find something she hadn't done. Still, he left her lips free to keep answering Theo, but he kept kissing at her neck and shoulder, while one of his hands slipped down to start teasing her from his end.
“We’ll be better,” Theo promised, scissoring his fingers to open her up enough for him. “We’ll make you feel so good,” he added. He knew they would. They loved her and she wanted something from them that Theo knew he and Dustin could give. He knew it was something any of them would give each other, no matter who wound up in the middle and needed both of them at once. “Let me know when you’re ready for me.”
All the movements Theo made, all his words, all of Dustin’s soft touches and kisses and his teasing, everything was starting to get to her. She knew in her bones that they would be better. They were already so much better than anyone she’d ever had before them. “Please,” Iv breathed, turning her head a little so the word was whispered into the air by Theo. “Ready, please.”
He nodded. “I got you baby,” he promised, kissing her. He shifted, adding more lube to himself and her. He got the angle right, starting slow. “Just breathe for me,” he said as he started to slip in, groaning against her skin. “Fuck, Dustin, she’s perfect. You’re perfect.”
As he moved, she exhaled like instructed and closed her eyes. Biting her lip, she pressed her head into Dustin’s shoulder as little sounds of pleasure, muffled behind her lips, wafted into the air between them. It had been a long while since she’d done this but it felt completely natural to be here with the two of them, clinging to Dustin while Theo moved. His praise washed over her and she reached behind her to squeeze Theo’s thigh as she adjusted.
This was all completely new to Dustin, but he was so wrapped up in it that he didn’t have time to feel out of his depth. No, he was there with the two people he loved the most in the world, the two people he trusted more than anything. He was exactly where he wanted to be, where he was wanted. He smiled when she pressed against his shoulder, and he looked over her shoulder to catch Theo’s eye. The smile got wider. “She is, and so are you,” he agreed with the sentiment. He was waiting for his own cue, but not in a rush, He ghosted his hand down Iv’s arm to where she was squeezing Theo’s thigh, and he added his own there.
Theo went slow, smiling as he looked up at Dustin and nodded. He ran his fingers through Iv’s hair, kissing whatever of her skin he could reach. “You feel so good baby. You tell him, tell him when you want him.” He knew that this was on Iv, when she was comfortable.
Ivanya was basically purring. She melted into their touches and barely heard Theo when he spoke, but as soon as he was settled she looked up to catch Dustin’s eyes. “Want you,” She mewled, but it was much more than just want. There was a deep need in her to feel them both and now that Theo was there, it only made her ache more for Dustin to join. “Now,” She added, her voice deeper than before and this time it wasn’t a request.
Maybe there was really something to that command sort of thing because it did things to him. So did seeing what Theo and Iv were doing, even without his joining in yet. Then again he'd watched them before and enjoyed every second of it. But when she demanded him, he didn't hesitate. He shifted closer, pulling her leg over his hip to give all of them more room, and he reached between them to slide in home. Which was an intensely different sensation than he was used to. It was tighter, he could feel Theo too. He gasped hard with a moan on the end of it, and his grip on their hands got tighter. Jesus, he hadn't known what it would feel like but damn. He swore with soft passion under his breath before he started to actually move.
“Fuck,” Theo swore out loud, not expecting to fucking feel Dustin against him, but apparently he could. He should have thought about that. He should have thought about how this was going to do him in faster than he thought possible. He felt Dustin move, steadying himself against Iv and taking his point from Dustin. He thrusted, slow, with the same pace as Dustin was. That was it, perfect. They were perfect together.
With the change in position and the addition of Dustin, Ivanya was a shaking mess. By the time they started moving, all she could feel was this perfect fullness and she couldn’t stop her voice from groaning out in their ears. This was like nothing she’d ever had before, nothing she’d expected to feel this incredible. She wanted to move with them but there was almost no way she could do anything other than be pressed between them, feeling them both move together. She didn’t know it, but she was panting, mouth open as another moan escaped.
Dustin was lost. He recognized in the back of his mind that he’d had zero idea what he was getting himself into here, but holy mother of god, he was going to dream about this. It was going to haunt him in the best way. He wasn’t able to speak, just kept moving along with Theo, his grip on control not going to last all that long. Not with this. It was far more than he thought possible.
Theo wasn’t any better than either one of them. He slipped his hand between them, cupping Iv’s breast, tugging at her nipples as they worked together. He was babbling. They were moaning, but he was nothing but incoherent praise, for Iv and how amazing she felt, for Dustin and how big he was, all of it. He really, really couldn’t stop.
Ivanya was on another planet. She had to be with how amazing this was. She finally was able to move a little, just a tiny bit but it added so much to her experience that her breath hitched in the process. She could hear the praise, the sounds of them both, the way their bodies felt with her and then Theo was giving her more and it pushed her even closer to that edge. Just a few seconds more of his actions and she hit, crying out as she clenched around both of them.
That was one thing that Theo had, he could talk like that, and Dustin appreciated it on every level. He was so lost that the build up was coming on strong, and when she hit, it undid him. He was dragged along with her, crying out himself like he didn’t usually do quite so loudly. But there it was, the vocalization of exactly how deep it rocked through him.
And Theo toppled with them, drug down by the sheer force of it. He could feel them both, immediately, and he groaned against Iv’s shoulder, thrusting twice before he came with them with a shout. He gripped them, both of them, and shuddered through it before eventually sagging with them. That was amazing. Incredible. They needed to do that again. When they could walk.
Heavy breaths poured onto Dustin’s shoulder as Iv shook in between them. She was high on bliss, her entire body tingling. Carefully, slowly, she let up on her grip on Theo’s thigh and realized somewhere in the back of her mind that she probably left a mark. Exhaling again, she let out a laugh. “Damn.”
Dustin was calming down slowly and when she spoke, he couldn’t help but exhale a laugh. “Yeah,” he agreed, voice a little hoarse. “That.” Because he didn’t even close to have the words. He shifted to kiss Iv, then reached over to pull Theo closer to kiss him too.
Theo eased himself out, only because he didn’t want to hurt her, relishing in that final slide against super sensitive skin. He pushed up enough to kiss Dustin, enjoying that before falling back on the bed on his back with a groan. “We do that again,” he declared even if he couldn’t really move.
Ivanya couldn’t move yet. When Theo left, she gave another soft whimper, pressing her head into Dustin’s shoulder again as she tried to calm down her breathing too. “Yes,” She said instantly after Theo’s demand. “Lots more.” Words, why were words so hard?
Dustin wasn’t wording well either. He simply shifted because he knew he needed to, and he used the last of his strength to move Iv over more toward Theo so they could all snuggle together in the middle of the bed. He collapsed back, giving himself a second to adjust. “I love you,” he said to them both.
Theo made space for Iv against him when Dustin moved her, fingers finding the hand with the rings he’d given her on it and his other hand reaching out to touch the charm added to Dustin’s dog tags. “Sap,” he teased, but the answer was in his voice. He loved them as well.
Iv liked being scooped up like a little doll. It was always a nice reminder of how strong Dustin was. She settled there in between her two loves, one hand in Theo’s and the other reaching out to hold Dustin’s jaw. “I love you more,” She told them both, finally letting her eyes drift shut as the need for sleep and snuggles overtook her.