Katie glared at James words. “Did you not hear that you kissed me before you jumped? Did you even want to leave the island with me?” she sighed as she looked down at her hands and then Hurley words made her look back at him. “Wait Charlie said he wasn’t meant to raise him? So unless someone hadn’t of jumped I would have ended up with him!” she looked over at James and then shook her head. “Do you really think I would leave you if he showed up here, I am your wife, not his.”