To Subaru his gift exchange buddy, a box of peppermint tea and a box of peppermint cocoa. In case he prefers chocolate over tea. ♥
For Kanda: More of the peppermint tea, in a nice teacup wrapped up with shimmery green foil. For Jun: A CD of new agey instrumental music. Because you have some chilling and relaxing to do. Also a few of the more positive books Lavi gave him, the philosophical books discussing the nature of humanity. For Naoya, Cross, and Lavi: A fancy leather-bound notebook For Alma: A solitaire peg game For Kitty: An elaborate shawl For Lenalee, Miranda, Saki, Himawari, Asuka, PM, and Lacus: A vase with a few yellow flowers For Road: A little flower-patterned keychain fob.
And little nutcracker figurines on keychains for, like, everyone else he's talked to more than once and is reasonably friendly with.
He feels bad about Saki's gift, because PUPPY, and he might yet decide to get a redo on Himawari's gift if time permits.