The wizarding aspect definitely threw a curve ball Connor couldn't account for because it didn't exist in his reality. He had learned though, that witches and wizards alike existed in Madison Valley. As did other creatures of myth and lore.
As long as no faeries from the Irish folklore showed up, he would try to be accepting of everything else. It was hard for him, but he'd been exposed multiple times and saw no other choice but acceptance.
'"American beer is crap," Connor agreed. "As is American whisky and everything else, for that matter. America is crap, basically."