[Clint signed out the best compound bow from work then went shopping. Blunt point arrows: check. Face paint: check. Dental floss: check. Rubber spiders: check. A half hour of prep then he waited for full dark before heading out to put his plan into action.
He had his targets planned out in order of location. He wanted to get from one to the next without any apparent pattern. He knew they'd contact each other after the first few, peg him as the culprit so he had a full schedule and plan of attack.
Starting at full dark and continuing until everyone he's targeted has gone to bed Clint shoots arrows into strategic directions guaranteed to make the rubber spider have the best impact...sometimes with faces. Players' choice. Some people...like Steve and Nat...gets targeted multiple times throughout the night.
Targets are: MCU people (and having babies does not preclude them), ALL Rogers facetwins, absolutely everyone in the farm house and its extensions, basically if he met and likes you you're spider prank targets. If you do not want your character to be targeted let me know!]