Ah, yes I did. But now I wish she wasn't hurting so much :( I want Remus to be happy, but by hurting someone who really did love him. I can change my viewpoint to see another perspective ;) Personally I think Tonks should have thrown more of a tantrum, and Remus should have been more sorry. It was like he felt "Oops, sorry made a mistake. Bye now!" without really understanding what he did to her. I don't know if I could forgive a guy for doing that to me just because he was "confused". I hope Tonks finds someone that she can love and really loves her back :)