[Smiles more at the kiss, because sigh you sap, but as soon as he feels the magic, recognizing it or what it is, he can't keep his eyes closed and blinks them open pretty much immediately to look at him - and takes just a long moment to study his face with the new blank eye]
... Aramis. [Honestly completely shocked. not because he doubted your feelings but because he understood why you hadn't returned the gesture before]