[ She never would. Although her eyes still widen slightly. He doesn't look anything like what she would have imagined a demon to look like. He's charming, with a ready smile and friendly personality. And she's not overly religious by any means, but of course everyone has a preconceived notion. ]
I wouldn't have guessed... I honestly couldn't figure it out. [ He doesn't really smell all that delicious, but it sounds like that is because he is so far removed from human. ] Maybe that's why you're so handsome!