Okay, just an OOC note. I'm cool with handwaving and having the Loki shows up for mind probe and evil sensing thing as requested by Cole and Parker. Could have happened maybe the day before or so. I think Penny would be there due to the tether, plus Ben and Andy also, as they're staying there til it's over. Not sure if Parker was present. Cole would have welcomed it, and it's cool if Erin didn't mind. He also has recording stuff if allowable, like a tape recorder and videocam (thinking that it's better to have something solid rather than hearsay, though there are 3-4 other witnesses).
Also, going from being told in the chat, the gaze isn't to sift through all memories, mostly just feelings and emotions at the time, intentions, thoughts, in addition to looking for any evil present (and not finding it since he's good). Intentions would be to just endure this vacation until he goes back to his life, mostly annoyance at the "he's evil" thing but not real anger about it, and also making sure penny feels comfortable and safe during this since he has a family too. That last part would have a "secret!" type vibe, he raised her in NYC just to keep her away from the mess and so she wouldn't be involved in it.
An extra idea is if Loki and Cole also talked. Cole would definitely understand about being called evil before their time, lol. I think it was mentioned that Loki can tell when someone is lying or not, or if there's deception. Since he is good at it, mwahahah Cole would have answered each question clearly. He'd also have probably given details about the point he had come from, how he liked doing his job to help other people, and fighting evil people. And probably that he moved on from Phoebe long ago, so that's not an issue either. The only real deception would be that he didn't outright confess to having a wife and kid, least not verbally, merely aside from saying he has his own life apart from all others in Lawrence, as he lived in NYC. REasoning for concealing it is more of a "I just don't want my family involved in that stuff, or to go through what I did with the sisters years ago when I first showed up, plus it's my way of staying away from them as per our arrangement" sort of for protection rather than any ulterior reasons.
Then when Loki left (I'd assume after telling them his assessment, as well as stating that he definitely isn't an evil guy, and anything else Loki would ike to mention), Cole would have an "See, I told you" type look (and with shaking head lol) at the others before walking into another section of the room, like the kitchen, or to the couch or something to pick up a book. He maybe wouldn't want to look at anyone for a while. So.. that's all I can think of. Questions, comments, ideas for post-probe reactions, or anything to add? Also, Erin, if I missed anything or need to change a part, let me know and I can edit. :)