(ooc: just kick me on AIM when it's my turn - I only get notifs after Lyddia replies and I honestly forget to check as often as I should for your replies :/ )
Ari was incredibly skeptical of what Toby was saying. She was buying it, up until he said that he was with a girl named Sarah. Presley's name was familiar to her though, so perhaps the other girl was a mutant like them? Then again, Ari couldn't remember any Sarah's that were Toby's age and from the island.
"You're out with a girl? Alone?" The idea was strange to Ari. She was used to only seeing young men and women together in public, Jewish settings where everyone in the community could keep an eye on them and make sure there wasn't any funny business going on. Perhaps he was smitten with the girl. After all, she had a nice Jewish first name - what could be better than being named after Sarah Imanu?
Her expression hardened when Eden was mentioned. "Oh. Why would you make a nice Jewish girl try on clothes for Eden?" Ariella would never forget what had happened at the Shabbos dinner table a few weeks ago, and she was clearly still bitter about it. "Who are her parents? There are a lot of Sarah's in the community that are your age, you know." Of course Ari was already trying to scope out who her son was being seen in public with.