She gathered that it was a joke, but she didn't find it very funny. Rather than make a scene (half because she was tired of fighting with him and half because she wanted the present he'd gotten her) she simply shot back, "Yeah, but you don't know him."
She turned from him before he could get a good look at her face to tell if she was serious and moved to her closet to withdraw the jersey she'd gotten him so long ago. It was still in its neatly wrapped box, begging to be opened.