Abby glared at Carter when he said that he thought she was happy with the guy she was dating. "You really thought I'd be happy with a frat boy, a future Fortune 500 owner, or a flute player?" She smirked right after she said it though and stole a quick kiss from him. "Tischies seem to be more my type, apparently."
When Carter finally said that he loved her, Abby's jaw literally dropped a little like something out of a cartoon. He hadn't even said it when they were dating and now they weren't together and he was admitting it. Everything was backwards. She was supposed to be the one crying and saying she loved him and he was the one who was supposed to be joking and playing off how serious this moment was.
But Abby closed her mouth when she realized that her jaw had dropped and went up on her tiptoes to kiss him again, a tear of happiness running down her cheek. Abby rested one hand on his cheek, wiping away the tears on his cheek with her thumb. "I love you too," she said through a big goofy grin. "But I swear, if you ever pull something like that again, I'll kill you myself." She jokingly reached up and put her hands around his neck, as if to strangle him.