Her reaction surprised him a little, and he found a multitude of different scenarios running through his head, of why she might not like it. Sure it was old, but he had thought it clean enough, despite the time it had spent with him, since the day she had thrown it at him. It had been his talisman for many years.
No, more than likely was that she somehow thought it was inappropriate to be giving her the same ring he had that first time. "Do you..." He cut himself off, not asking if she didn't actually like it. "I can get you another one."