John shouldn't have been surprised about the question after all that was happening but this was still new to him so his facial expression waned before slowly shaking his head. The other gentleman didn't look like he was used to witches either but he seemed to know a good amount of information. Enough that Wick could take a chance on for now.
"No witches or magic in a logical sense," But his world was definitely not ordinary. Rules would dictate you didn't show your cards in this situation. In his world everyone knew him, or thought they did, and he was still alive. Blind faith and sheer will would keep him going here too. "I deal with the mob and death for expense. I tried to retire but that world is too thick. Here it's better no one knows John Wick."