Her eyes widened comically. Then her expression shifted to an intense thoughtfulness as she began mentally going back through their interactions together over the years, looking for those missed hints. After what was probably way too long, she remembered she hadn't said anything and Shay was probably freaking out.
"Wow. Either you are much better at hiding it than you thought, or I'm kind of an idiot. "So what would you say if I said I'm feeling the same way now?"