"OH please. As if I need that much baked goods. Your welcome to it." Suspicious as she was of new people she wasn't gonna send someone away who was new and lost and hungry. She'd learned to trust at least a little while here. Besides, he couldn't be a mark, they had all been chased out already. She doubted very much with their security that one could slip by.
"So, what's your name? I'm Mary. And I'm not a crazy witch that has a gingerbread house and lures unsuspecting people in like that or anything. Just so you know." They were all weird here, but it didn't mean they ate each other. Rule number 1.