At first it sounded like Damon was defending his claim to her which Elena had thought the two would have talked a lot sooner but things seemed to get weird between the two as she listened in. Needing to see what was going on, specially when she heard Stefan mention handcuffs, Elena pushed the door open just a little bit more. She pushed it until she got a perfect view of the bed and the brothers on it. Her eyes went wide and she flushed at the side of them together. What was going on?