Finn would probably be disappointed. Rachel knew this. Finn probably knew it too. But at least he'd be able to say he'd been brave enough to try it. And if by some miracle he did like them, well that was just one more thing they could eat together. It was a very short list.
She smiled when he kissed her, because she felt the same. It would suck without him here. She just still couldn't believe he wanted to be with her. She was not the girl who was picked, not over a pretty cheerleader like Quinn though she understood why that had ended. Finn had definitely pleasantly surprised her.