I hope you don't think I disliked the story, because I really liked it and wouldn't have stuck with it otherwise. I think it's one of the most interesting I have read. Your characters were very real and I totally loved Sam and Andrew. I just disapprove of what Remus and Teddy did in letting it all go too far. So until the last two chapters I held out hope they'd come to their senses, unfortunately they didn't because they were too selfish. As you said, very flawed characters and you showed that well.