"You expect me to believe you'd just come with me, willingly?" Lucifer asked with a pointed look. "That's a good one, Sammy. But last I checked, rape victims didn't go with their captor willingly."
Lucifer was being a dick, and he didn't mind. He liked seeing Sam struggle, and he liked to see just how angry he could make the hunter. It wasn't like it made much of a difference now. Perhaps it would help to build the bond they used to have. Lucifer definatly wouldn't mind.