Books include but are not limited to Magical Hieroglyphs and Logograms and Olde and Forgotten Bewitchments and Charmes. The plushie puppy can be warmed up with heating charms for snugglings and soothings, particularly after full-moony times.
Lily
Self-stirring cauldron (for potion-making once the bump gets bigger.)
James, Sirius, Peter
Caradoc
Dedalus
A hat rack
Jo, Bethany, Tibby, Meaghan, Mary, Hestia
Dorcas
Tiny little books about graphic stick figure art.
Emmeline
The book Sun, Moon, Space, and the Bigger Fancier Names You Can Call Them To Impress the Unaware (and other stories)
Grady (although technically Katie)
The Order (including the above!)
Gift baskets with jars filled with chocolate-covered espresso beans and M&Ms.