This is the second time for me and I still had that reaction. If one magical portal kidnapping individuals from different worlds is nonsense, then a second kidnapping more from infinite version of those worlds, including worlds with the same type of portal, is beyond the limits of madness.
But here we are. Once the shock wears off, then the secondary outrage/confusion/emotion of the moment, it isn't a terrible place to be. Given some futures here, it's not terrible at all.