Rosalie listened quietly to what Ella was saying, petulant scowl growing on her face. "I don't think it sounds selfish. It's not just us losing, it's him, if he goes back to just himself all alone in R1 for the rest of his life." She didn't share Ella's romanticized view of lying either. "He might be angry, but he wouldn't hate us. And we don't have to lie then, just not tell him everything." She would never have considered a well-intentioned lie with the gravity Ella seemed to be giving it.