Hah, that definitely works! It's just as easy to get some good plot whilst helping people out!
Scott's good gift should most definitely be his suit! His bad gift doesn't have to be anything horrible, mind. It's just going to have to even out against the suit. My first thought, maybe, would be the "Worlds Greatest Grandma" trophy. Not because it's bad, but because it's a firm reminder that he's in a place that Cassie isn't.