Tabitha didn't respond to the face he pulled because if he wasn't going to go out and get it himself - which she had a feeling he wouldn't - she would just get it for him and get it delivered. She really needed to teach him about online shopping one of these days. That way at least he'd have properly stocked cupboards. One day, maybe not today. Teasing him about fruit was probably far enough for one day. She didn't, popular to contrary belief, enjoy teasing him or Asher about being old and out of touch. What she enjoyed was their reactions.
She reached out for the cup and took a cursory sniff, glancing up at Sully with a smile tugging at the corner of her lips even though she was clearly trying to smother it. Unlike the others from their time together that day, however, that smile crept up into her eyes.
After taking a sip, and then another one, and then a third - just to be sure - Tabitha nodded. "Best one yet, I think," she told him confidently, offering it back for him to try. "That's actually, yeah, pretty good."