Well, that doesn't sound so far removed from tie-in novels and the like...
[ten minutes later]
Oh. Oh my. Well that's just...
When did the second half of "If you can't say anything nice" become "launch into a three-paragraph rant disguised as a poor attempt at characterisation"? Not that I'm familiar enough with CSA to know the characterisation all that well, but what happened to just ignoring characters - or people, for that matter - that you don't like?
You know, sometimes I wish I was just a little less curious.