Or you could simply include two different versions of the same game, and therefore introduce more people to what you so enjoy. I don't see why you couldn't have two categories in general. It wouldn't be a challenge.
No one has asked for only the magical version to be available, which is a point you have conveniently ignored. Both should, and would, still be available. Those who wish to play one or the other could. Those who wish to play both could. If changing the entire set up means you ought to be considerate of everyone, instead of only one portion, then yes, I believe you should do something else. This is clearly not working.