Would it have killed him to step back from his reference so he wouldn't do things like paint square ceiling lights and then tube lighting on the floor. Seriously, how do you paint a missing light fixture to highlight something, and then make it a dark spot instead.
Also, that's seriously not how reflections work. Has he been reffing from PsDisasters?
I'm always torn with this dude. He'll make technically or aesthetically nice covers, and then screw up composition or physics or something nuts that I would expect someone with a certain level of art skillz to not miss.