Wish: Micah C [With a little bit of "Sam"]
[It's 0001 and Micah finally gets his wish. This Cupid, being the type to believe that you can't possess an individual without their consent to do so, opts very a very literal translation of 'possess.' Micah's bones shift, his hair goes long and dark, his genitals recede, and his breasts (or perhaps hers) grow until he inhabits a mirror perfect image of Sam Alexander. What has he won? Well, her (body) of course. What have 'they' lost? Perhaps only the satisfaction of finding him now. If Cupid could have had his way, they would have, but making sure that a real, living girl doesn't end up with Micah is the best he can do.
As for Sam Alexander, she's wherever she was before, unharmed, untouched, and undisturbed in her own skin. How long will Micah possess the body of her doppleganger? Cupid doesn't bother to specify.