Yes, the same thing happens to me, while reading a fic.

Sometimes I read some of the comments before reading, to get other opinions first. If the most of them positiv like 'great, fantastic, i love it....', I give it a try. Often I read just the first few sentences and think: 'Are they nuts, that's crab, I dont understand a word!'

But it happens the other way around too. Fics other people don't like at all I like very much.
Everybody has just a diffrent taste I would say.

I can't give a opinion to your fic now, because I haven't read it yet, maybe tomorrow if I have time.