"But!" Toby's worried exclaimation sounded a bit out of place when he couldn't find an actual believable excuse to follow it. There was really no reason he could think of why he shouldn't go with Claire, and he knew Sarah would just be more mad if she heard that he had not listened to Claire.
He sighed, taking a few clearly reluctant steps forward. Though Toby didn't think that anything REALLY bad could happen to his big sister with Peter watching over her, that didn't mean that he wanted to be far away from her. "Ok, but I don't want to be gone for long. I was going to make Sarah some more soup for supper."