Something I thought to be unthinkable: I have found a show that I hate iconning more than Criminal Minds. That show is Supernatural.
However, I will get through it for the sake of Misha Collins and his gigantic, beautiful blue woobie eyes. Also: "This isn't funny, Dean! The voice says I'm almost out of minutes!" Many of these icons are sort of questionable, given that the show is pitch black half the time, but they're not so much so that I'm not posting them. …There are also not enough icons of hippie!Cas from "The End." There aren't any spoilers, but there is a doofy smile.